Cast List:
| Annie | Haleigh King |
|---|---|
| Pepper | Elizabeth Gentry |
| Duffy | Abby Hill |
| July | Emma Hill |
| Tessie | Lydia Fruits |
| Kate | Madilyn Biddle |
| Molly | Brooklyn Woolwine |
| Miss Hannigan | Aurora Murdock/Caroline Bowling |
| Oliver Warbucks | Ben Oppy |
| Grace Farrell | Shaeleigh Hreskowsky |
| Rooster | Henry Keller |
| Lily St Regis | Lashah Maish |
| Mrs. Drake | Elizabeth Nunan |
| Mrs. Greer | Madelyn Schnelle |
| Mrs. Pugh | Jordanna Troutman |
| Cecille | Jolie Hoenshell |
| Annette | Harper Allen |
| Chauffeur | Isabella Roberts |
| Apple Seller | Madelyn Roberts |
| Officer Ward | Easton Barker |
| Bert Healy | Carter Hodges |
| Bundles McCloskey | Carter Scott |
| FDR | Judah Hoenshell |
| Louisa Howe | Avery Hannum |
| Star to Be | Miciah Maish |
| Dog Catcher | Walter Samuels |
| Cop | Tovi Powell |
| Usherettes | Ada Simmons, Kailyn Howard |
| Sound Effects Man | Liam Howard |
Orphan Crew
Lily Baldwin, Caroline Brooks, Londyn Gayler, Jacey Hoenshell, Lizzy Pithout, Elizabeth Ryker, Aria Seward, Ingrid Sieferman
Servants/Maids
Braelin Goins, Elliott Hamilton, Everly Morgan, Elliott Peck, Charlotte Powell, Lynlee Peters, Keira Toomey, Brooklyn Vaughn
New Yorkers
Summer Binch,Clara Brown, Laura Hodge, Kaybree Hughes, Molly Hutchinson, Adelaide Lindsay, Anna Lindsay, Alyanna Morgan, Myla Samuels, Kayla Schnelle, Madeline Stephenson
NYC Kids
Jacob Fossnock, Javan Hoenshell, Michael Nunan
The Littlest Orphans
Izabela Brewer, Ruby Frees-Williams, Vera Fruits, Harper Hubble, Cora Keller, Iris Sieferman
and featuring Oliver Frees as Sandy
